Our Blog

Building a Feedback Culture: the 2 Questions for HR


The Idea of a Feedback Culture

Many organizations are looking for ways to build a feedback culture. They do this because the organization will benefit from more intensive and qualitative feedback. We know that feedback can be beneficial under specific circumstances. But we also know that in the majority of cases feedback does not work.

So it’s crucial to get it right. And so if you want to build a feedback culture, you should carefully design the approach.

In the past feedback the design of a feedback approach was very formal and linked to a performance management approach. The general experience with these approaches is that they have not delivered much value. More, performance management systems were seen as a burden by managers, and often demotivated employees.

The role of HR in this is crucial. HR is the architect of the system and should design the process according to the company’s culture, the dominant leadership style and the general work context.

But to be honest, HR has often failed to do this. For several reasons.

  • HR sees a performance management system as a source of data. This leads to an overengineering of the system and an obligation to document too much. If the target of the approach is gathering data, the approach is losing its value.
  • HR underestimates the role of the leader in performance management and does not involve leaders enough in the design. We should see performance management as a business process aimed at aligning, motivating and coordinating people.
  • Systems that support the feedback approach should be as light as possible. Never forget that a software platform should decrease the effort both managers and employees should do to ask and receive feedback.

Two Design Questions to Ask

But after the design of the system, the role of HR is basically limited to advocacy and support. And in this, there are only two questions HR should be interested in.

  1. How can we make sure there is sufficient feedback?
  2. How can we make sure the feedback is of good quality?

The first question seems to be easy to answer. It’s not. Feedback will only be sufficient when both the leaders and the employees think it’s sufficient. So it’s difficult to define a frequency requirement. The golden rule is: give enough feedback to satisfy the needs of both parties involved.

That also responsibilities both the individual employee and the leader. If they do not feel they receive or give enough feedback, they should take initiative.

In general most organisations will put forward a minimal number of feedback conversations. And very often this is only once or twice a year. But if we are honest, feedback should be informal, timely, continuous, etc. So asking a minimal frequency of once a year is not very helpful in establishing that feedback culture. The answer should be as much as needed.

So every encounter, every meeting, every conversation could and even should contain opportunities for feedback. Only when feedback is engrained in every day life, will there be a feedback culture.

Only when feedback is engrained in every day life, will there be a feedback culture.

The second question is even more difficult to answer. When is feedback of high quality? To me there are three aspects:

  1. Is the feedback actionable? Can the person receiving the feedback actually something with it? Doing something with feedback sounds vague, but in general feedback is oriented towards behavioural change. So feedback will be actionable if it enables someone to do things better, differently, more effectively or when it helps people to acquire new behaviour.
  2. Is the feedback motivating? Is the feedback given in such a way that the person receing it wants to do something with it? So if the feedback does not appeal to the needs of the person, it won’t be motivating.
  3. Is the feedback fair? Feedback should not be an evaluation. The moment someone feels that the feedback is unfair, they will feel aggressed. Again, this is tricky. And that is why negative feedback should be given in an non-aggressive , non violent way. And that is why feedback should be actionable and not mixed with evaluation.

How will you know if the feedback has been of high quality? Just ask for feedback.

Feedback culture defined

Building a feedback culture is not easy. In a feedback culture people give and ask each other feedback continuously and informally. It is normal to give feedback as a way of sharing information about how things get done. 

Performance Management Systems include feedback and they have their role to play in supporting and facilitating feedback.

However, often they are over engineered and seen as a burden, rather than a help.

In this article you find the two relevant questions to ask when working on feedback within your organization. 

Get in touch

The Three Levels of Strategy Execution


About Strategy

Organisations need to reconsider the way they shape the strategic process. The time that this process is linear has gone. In the past strategy was a logic sequence of definition, execution and evaluation. It was enough to define targets and cascade them downwards.Read More

When the Number Becomes the Target – On Motivation.


The Story of the Priest

A catholic Priest prepared his sermon for the Sunday Mass. Every week he wrote a sermon which he ‘performed’ in three churches, spread across the city. In total about 30 people would hear his words.Read More

Never Forget Your Values.

As many organisations are heading for heavy waters, we should not forget the question of moral leadership. Never forget your values, David Ducheyne argues in a plea for a human approach of difficult decisions.Read More

CEO Succession – The King is Dead. Long Live the King

The new CEO

 A company in the hospitality business hired a new CEO, who came from a different industry. As it goes, the CEO went through a short period of induction before he came on stage to address a group of employees. He was kind of nervous about what he could say to these people who worked in an industry he did not know. He thought he had to be inspirational. So what he did marked the end of his reign. He took a powerpoint deck on leadership and governance from his previous company, changed the layout and presented it to the audience.Read More

Does Working Smart Lead to a Better Life?

When Strategies Do not Work

10 signals to see if your company is (not) future proof.

This blog is about the 10 signals that can help you to determine whether or not the organisation you work for is in good shape and future proof.Read More

Why did Soldiers Fight in World War I?


Today 100 years ago, the first world war ended. A conflict with hundreds of thousands of casualties. The Great War, as it was known before there was a second conflict, still fascinates us. Apart from all the historical analyses I have a question about motivation. Why did soldiers fight during World War 1? What was their motivation to leave the trenches across the front and be maimed and slaughtered?Read More

One Year of Entrepreneurship

The First Year

A year has gone by since I have left the company I had worked for for 11 years. Many people thought I had married that company as I felt and behaved like an ambassador, representing it with passion in the outside world. And in many ways this organisation defined who I was, or who I had become.Read More

Privacy Settings
We use cookies to enhance your experience while using our website. If you are using our Services via a browser you can restrict, block or remove cookies through your web browser settings. We also use content and scripts from third parties that may use tracking technologies. You can selectively provide your consent below to allow such third party embeds. For complete information about the cookies we use, data we collect and how we process them, please check our Privacy Policy
Consent to display content from Youtube
Consent to display content from Vimeo
Google Maps
Consent to display content from Google